Factors That Influence the Acceptance of Corruption in Brazil

The demonstration against government and corruption in the The demonstration against government and corruption in the Esplanada dos Ministerios (Marcello Casal Jr / Agência Brasil) (http://www.coha.org/combatting-grand-corruption-in-brazil/)

By Sergio Guedes Reis, UCLA Master of Social Science ‘18

Citizens all over the world consistently rank corruption as one of the most important public issues of our time. For instance, global market research firm IPSOS polled 21 thousand people from 28 countries and found that 35 percent of respondents cited corruption as the most important problem facing the globe today. A close second was ‘unemployment,’ which was mentioned by 34 percent of respondents.

In Brazil, a large-scale criminal investigation initiated in 2014 has unveiled a multi-billion dollar money laundering and bribery scandal involving almost every political party, as well as some of the major engineering and contracting firms and state-controlled oil companies. The subsequent political crisis ultimately led not only to the ousting of President Dilma Rousseff in 2016, but also a severe decline in people’s trust of institutions.

Interestingly, while narratives about the seemingly endemic nature of corruption in Brazil are widespread, polls suggest that actual levels of corruption may be much lower than the average rates found in other Latin American countries. That said, it is very hard to measure corruption, as it inherently happens under the radar. Taking this issue into account, watchdog organizations and survey companies usually look to gauge citizens’ perceptions of ongoing rates of corruption in their countries, ask local experts for their views on that matter, or even interview contractors about their experiences negotiating with public officers.

So in what circumstances do people accept engagement in corrupt activities or believe that corruption is positive? And why do Brazilians believe that corruption is their #1 problem, when polls consistently show that only a small percentage of citizens claim that they have had to bribe a public official themselves?

Based on this paradox, I decided to investigate what factors influence the tolerance for corruption in Brazil. After all, if so many people think corruption is a big problem in Brazil and nonetheless only a few admit engaging in corrupt practices, then it becomes crucial to understand whether certain conditions provide more room for corruption to happen than others.

In order to do so, I used two of the most recent Latin American surveys on public opinion, the 2016 Latinobarometer and the 2017 Latin American Public Opinion Project (LAPOP) surveys.

Then, I defined 3 basic forms of tolerance for corruption:

1) When citizens say they accept “corrupt, but efficient governments”

2) When they state that “bribing is sometimes acceptable”

3) When they declare that they do not feel personally obliged to report a case of corruption

There are several interpretations to why corruption exists in a society. For example, authors argue that people who advocate for authoritarian values are more prone to accept corruption, because they believe that being compliant with democratic procedures does not solve one’s own problems and thus people must take illegal, yet efficient action to achieve their goals. Others propose that low levels of trust (in other people and in institutions in general) are positively related to corruption, as discrediting others leads subjects to adopt more self-interested behavior to get things done.

I opted to test variables associated with these and other possible explanations in order to comprehend the issue at stake.

The most important findings I had were:

  • Depending on the type of tolerance towards corruption, a different set of factors was more strongly associated with it. Variables associated with authoritarian values and socio-economic and demographic attributes (such as low development, high income and inequality) were more correlated with acceptance of corrupt (but efficient) governments, justification of bribery, and low levels of trust with avoidance of reporting cases of corruption.
  • Individuals who trusted in people in general, had confidence in certain institutions or were well informed about them (the Parliament, political parties, and even groups from civil society) were also more prone to accept corruption.
  • Citizens who stated they believed in typical markers of the status quo (such as claims about the fairness in the distribution of income, the impartiality of the Judiciary branch or the existence of equality of opportunity among Brazilians) were also more likely to accept corruption.

Survey-based research can usually only capture subjects’ opinions regarding a given topic, and not their actual practices. So, it is not possible to state that a moral agreement with corruption would imply acting corruptly in a real setting. Nonetheless, a pro-corrupt attitude may represent an open door for the occurrence of rule violations if the context allows. In the Brazilian case, the presence of structural factors (such as inequality and developmental levels) as predictors of tolerance towards corruption suggest this issue to have deep roots in the country’s social fabric. It also indicates that anticorruption solutions need to be connected to welfare and redistribution policies if they are to become more efficient and effective.

Future research considering other countries, cultures and contexts may disentangle other factors and particular mechanisms through which corruption becomes an acceptable enterprise. For Brazil, at least, it seems that fostering democratic values, political accountability, social equality and education would offer a way out of the large-scale turmoil it currently faces.

 

Sergio Guedes Reis is a Federal Auditor at the Brazilian Ministry of Transparency and a 2018 graduate of UCLA’s Master of Social Science (MaSS) program.

6 replies
  1. Pedro Vef
    Pedro Vef says:

    In June 2017, the prosecutor-general charged the president with corruption for accepting a $152,000 bribe from Batista, and in September with obstruction of justice and racketeering. The charges failed to obtain the two-thirds approval required by Congress for it to move forward in the STF, and Temer survived an  impeachment vote in August of that year. Even so, at least eight cabinet ministers or top aides have stepped down since Temer took office due to the revelations from Lava Jato and other probes. “His kitchen cabinet has been decimated,” says Taylor. Several smaller political parties have withdrawn their support for the Temer administration.   
    By the way! The best essay writing service – https://www.easyessay.pro/
    And Happy New Year!

  2. KatzimsFah
    KatzimsFah says:

    Если вы приняли решение получить моментальный займ, вам нужно определиться с компанией, где оптимально взять займ online. Сейчас не все организации оформляют срочные займы. Если вы желаете получить мгновенные займы, вам нужно просмотреть перечень организаций, которые предоставляют займы на приемлемых условиях.

    На все-займы-тут.рф находится каталог компаний, которые предоставляют быстрые займы людям. На портале реально найти разные МФО, прочитать отклики и определиться с условиями займа. Большое количество организаций предоставляют деньги на выгодных условиях. Получить займ реально в наши дни с паспортом.

    Для того, чтобы человек мог получить мгновенный онлайн займ необходимо выбрать компанию, изучить параметры займа. Каждый мужчина попадал в ситуацию, когда финансы могут потребоваться безумно срочно. Братья не всегда могут помочь финансово. Из-за этого необходимо изучить возможность взять online займ на карту.

    Если вы стремитесь получить для себя [url=http://все-займы-тут.рф/]займ онлайн на карту круглосуточно без проверок без отказа[/url] , вам необходимо выбрать условия. Если вы добросовестный заемщик, финансы будут переведены вам в моментальные сроки. Получить деньги вы можете в рублях на конкретный срок. Нужно подчеркнуть, что сервис гарантирует максимальную конфиденциальность. На портале собраны МФО, которые всегда идут людям навстречу. Новые люди также не будут ощущать какого-то дискомфорта. Отличные условия кредитования также существуют для многих клиентов.

    У вас существует возможность получить микрозаймы быстрее, чем это проходит в банковских учреждениях. Вам не надо собирать справки. Моментальные займы – универсальный выход, если вам в сжатые сроки потребовались деньги. Для получения средств следует заполнить анкету на сайте МФО. С вами моментально свяжется менеджер и обсудит все детали.

    Если вы не уверены, где вы можете найти каталог лучших МФО, можете смело просмотреть его на сайте. Лучшие микрофинансовые организации есть на портале. У всех МФО есть техническая поддержка. Получить кредит можно на банковскую карту любого банка. Вы можете также получить средства за 10 минут без лишних вопросов от банковских сотрудников.

    После того, как ваша заявка будет одобрена, вы получите подтверждение. Более 90% заявок получают одобрение. Оформить мирозайм реально даже через мобильный телефон. Для этого понадобится иметь выход в сеть. Также вам понадобится паспорт и банковская карта, куда вы будете получать средства.

  3. ShowNug
    ShowNug says:

    Looking for the best app to watch free movies on your Android phone? Then your should check Showbox app. This is the most famous app today that has a big library of tv shows and movies. This app is also available for pc users. But your need to download it first to enjoy free films [url=http://showbox-all.com]Showbox app on PC[/url]

  4. LorineClekallorenar
    LorineClekallorenar says:

    Sposob awarii dysku zewnetrznego okresla, w jaki sposob zabrac sie za naprawe i ostatecznie jak zostanie przywrocony dostep do danych.
    Istnieje wiele roznych technik naprawy uszkodzonego nosnika – np. zewnetrzny dysk twardy, ktory zostal upuszczony, klikajac wymaga zupelnie innej metody naprawy niz na przyklad dysk, na ktorym wystepuje uszkodzenie oprogramowania ukladowego. Naprawa dysku twardego i proces odzyskiwania danych jest skomplikowany i czesto czasochlonny, dlatego powinien on zostac podjety tylko przez profesjonalna firme zajmujaca sie odzyskiwaniem danych, taka jak np. MiP Data & Forensic

  5. ThomasNer
    ThomasNer says:

    Привет хотим представить вам партнерку по [url=http://onebetbest.com/push.php]пуш монетизации[/url].
    Пуш подписки дают отличную возможность манетизировать ваш сайт в пасивном режиме. Этот способ дохода обсюлютно легален.
    Приглашаем Вас начать зарабатывать на своем сайте или по партнерской программе где вы получаете отчисления от приглашенных рекламодателей и вэбмастеров.
    Всем кому интересен данный вид заработка можно перейти по [url=http://onebetbest.com/push.php]ССЫЛКЕ(КЛИК)[/url] для регистрации.

  6. Kelanteks
    Kelanteks says:

    Prednisone Side Effects Levitra Vardenafil 10 Mg Propecia How Long For Results 1 Mg [url=http://cialonlineno.com]cialis tablets for sale[/url] Generique Lioresal 25mg 25 Clomid 50mg Viagra Pfizer Prezzo Best Deal On Silagra Viagra Et Cialis Pas Cher [url=http://clanar.com]generic viagra[/url] Viagra Cialis Comparazione Where To Buy Diclofenac In England Kamagra Achat France [url=http://ciali20mg.com]cialis[/url] Buspar Venta Cialis Generico Espana Cheapeast Doxycycline Colco Coded Amoxil Cialis Apotheke Osterreich Propecia Daily Dosage Merck [url=http://via100mg.com]viagra prescription[/url] Cephalexin Clindamycin Canadian Cheap Cialis [url=http://mdsmeds.com]cheap cialis[/url] Zithromax For Copd Meglio Viagra Cialis O Levitra Do I Need Prescription For Cialis Lyme Disease Amoxicillin El Levitra Funciona [url=http://sildenaf75.com]viagra[/url] No Precription Synthroid 125mcg Daily

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *